Mixed
To maximize relative muscular effort (RME) and mechanical loading of the knee extensors during squats, practitioners must use deep squat depths (greater than 105 degrees of knee flexion) rather than increasing barbell load, as load has minimal effect on knee extensor RME.
If your goal is to build strong, large quadriceps, stop obsessing over how much weight is on the bar. Focus on squatting deep—specifically, going beyond parallel (past 105 degrees of knee bend). The study shows that simply adding weight to a shallow or parallel squat does little to stimulate the knee extensors. You can use lighter weights and still get a massive stimulus by ensuring you hit that deep range of motion. Conversely, if you want to target your glutes and calves, you need to use heavier loads, even if you squat shallower.
To maximize loading of the knee extensors to enhance performance, squat depths greater than 105° knee flexion are required... given that increasing barbell load from 50% to 90% 1RM has virtually no effect on knee extensor RME, this strategy would be ineffective for training the knee extensors.
Why this rating
Controlled biomechanical study with inverse dynamics on strength-trained subjects, though limited to women and specific depth ranges.
Source
Effect of Squat Depth and Barbell Load on Relative Muscular Effort in Squatting
Megan A. Bryanton et al. · The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research · 2012
This is one finding among thousands. Every one is graded and traced to its source, so you can see what the evidence actually supports. Browse the research →